Wartime Cakes Made Without Sugar (And Still Tasty)

When sugar, eggs, milk, and butter disappeared from kitchen shelves during the wars, so did the idea of a “normal” cake. But guess what?

People still found a way to bake something sweet, warm, and comforting. Wartime cakes—also called War Cakes or Depression Cakes—were born out of pure necessity, and somehow, they were still pretty darn tasty.

These weren’t fancy. No buttercream. No whipped toppings. But they were a symbol of creativity and survival. And they proved one thing: flavor doesn’t have to come from luxury. It can come from raisins, a few spices, and a little bit of courage.

• The Great Depression Cake: Eggless, Milkless, Butterless Cake
• Depression-Era Crazy Cake: The Chocolate Cake That Needs No Eggs, Butter, or Milk
• Carrot Cake (Wartime Version) – A Frugal Yet Delicious Treat
• Crumb-Topped Vegan Coffee Cake Straight from a 1950s Brunch

What Makes Wartime Cakes So Unique

These cakes skipped all the things we think a cake needs. No sugar. No eggs. No butter. No milk.

Instead, people leaned on what they had:

• Molasses, honey, maple syrup, or raisins for sweetness
• Water in place of milk
• Bacon grease or shortening instead of butter
• Baking soda or powder stood in for eggs

And then they added flavor—good old pantry spices like cinnamon, clove, and nutmeg. Some even added a pinch of salt to keep things balanced. These weren’t just cakes—they were a lesson in survival through simplicity.

The Boil-and-Bake Method

One popular trick was boiling the ingredients first.

You’d toss raisins, your sugar substitute (like brown sugar or honey), water, shortening, and spices into a pot. Let it all simmer together for five minutes. Then you’d cool it down, stir in flour and baking soda, and send it off to the oven.

That method gave the cake more depth of flavor—and helped make up for the missing richness from eggs and butter.

A Taste of History: The Canadian War Cake

The Canadian version of the War Cake was more than dessert—it was a love letter in loaf form.

Wives, mothers, and grandmas baked them and shipped them off to soldiers overseas. The smell alone reminded homesick soldiers of Sunday kitchens and peacetime.

Here’s how it usually went:
Step 1: Boil brown sugar, shortening, water, raisins, and salt
Step 2: Let it cool
Step 3: Mix in cinnamon, cloves, mace, baking soda, and flour
Step 4: Bake low and slow for about an hour

No frosting. No fuss. Just a moist, spicy loaf that kept well and lifted spirits.

The Secret Ingredient? Spices and Ingenuity

Flavor was everything. People had to cover up the lack of butter and eggs somehow.

That’s where spices came in strong. Cinnamon, cloves, nutmeg, and even black pepper turned a humble batter into something exciting. Raisins and other dried fruits gave bursts of sweetness and kept the cake from drying out.

And even when molasses or brown sugar wasn’t available, people got scrappy. They used carrot pulp, applesauce, or even rosehip powder, which added a bit of vitamin C and a touch of tartness.

So Were They Actually Good?

Surprisingly, yes.

These cakes weren’t fluffy or light, but they were rich in their own way. Moist, chewy, spiced—think fruitcake but less dense. And today, many folks who try them again say they hold up better than expected.

Modern experiments with jaggery, soy flour, or monk fruit sweeteners have shown it’s totally possible to make a sugar-free cake taste good. You just have to shift your expectations. Wartime cakes didn’t try to copy the bakery-style sponge. They created something new.

Why They Still Matter Today

These cakes are more than just quirky historical recipes.

They remind us of what people can do when the shelves are empty and the future’s uncertain. They tell stories of “housesoldiers”—the home cooks who fought food shortages with wooden spoons and tin pans.

And honestly? They’re still practical today. Whether you’re avoiding sugar, going dairy-free, or just love a good vintage bake, wartime cakes are worth trying.

Final Crumb

Wartime cakes weren’t just desserts. They were proof that people don’t stop baking when times get hard—they get more creative.

Next time you’re out of eggs, don’t panic. Just channel your inner 1940s cook, boil some raisins, throw in some spice, and bake a little resilience into your day.